The legendary value investor missed a few major issues faced by Alibaba
- Munger’s investment in Alibaba has priced in a management discount.
- Munger misjudged Alibaba’s competitive position.
- Munger underestimated Chinese government’s crackdown on Alibaba.
In my previous article Alibaba:A Sinking Ship, I laid out my view of Alibaba’s current and potentially structural long-term issues. As I mentioned, I have followed Alibaba Group Holding (BABA) since its IPO in 2014 and witnessed its glory days as well as its decline. When my investing idol Charlie Munger (Trades, Portfolio) took a stake in Alibaba in Q1 of 2021, I was very surprised. Since then Munger has admitted that investing in Alibaba was one of the biggest mistakes he has ever made. In this article, I’ll discuss what Charlie Munger (Trades, Portfolio) missed on Alibaba, based on my observations.
First of all, I think Charlie Munger (Trades, Portfolio) knew about Alibaba’s bureaucratic culture and Jack Ma’s legacy negative influence. He criticized Jack Ma’s idiotic behavior in a CNBC interview he did together with Warren Buffett (Trades, Portfolio). His exact words were:
“Jack Ma is one of the swingers. He basically gave a speech when he said to a, to a one-party state, ‘Well, you guys are a bunch of jerks, don’t know what you’re doing. And I know what I’m doing, and I’m gonna do it better.’ And he was gonna wade into banking and no rules and just do whatever he pleased. You don’t want a swinger to run. The banks have the implicit guarantee of the government, and you don’t, you don’t want to let any swinger run a bank. “
Later during the 2023 DJCO shareholder meeting, Munger said:
“Jack Ma got way out of line by popping off the way he did to the Chinese government. Of course, it hurt Alibaba.”
Therefore, clearly Munger’s investment decision has priced in a management discount.
The other mistake Munger admitted is that he was wrong in judge Alibaba’s business model, during the 2023 DJCO meeting, Munger said:
“In thinking about Alibaba, I got charmed by their position in the Chinese internet and didn’t stop to realize, ‘they’re still a god-damn retailer.’”
I think Munger’s mistake here is more than not realizing Alibaba’s still a retailer. His mistake is not having the daily user experience of Taobao, T-Mall and their competitors. To his credit, I knew Munger ordered some items from Alibaba’s competitor PDD Holdings
Not on the ground in China is Munger’s disadvantage, because if you live in China, it’s very noticeable that consumers have been switching from Taobao to Pinduoduo over the past few years. It’s also very obvious that Douyin (Chinese version of TikTok) and to some extent, Kuaishou has also taken Taobao’s market share.
Therefore, while Munger admitted that Alibaba’s still a god-damn retailer, it looks like he didn’t do enough research on Taobao and T-Mall’s competitive environment. This is his biggest mistake.
Thirdly, Munger probably underestimated the influence of Chinese government on Chinese internet platform companies. Over the past few years, Alibaba has many negative social media coverage, some of the negative coverage is from government media. It is clear that the Chinese government targeted Alibaba in all major business units. On April 10th of 2021, Chinese government fined Alibaba for a record of 18 billion yuan ($2.75 billion), after an anti-monopoly probe found that Alibaba had abused its dominant market position for several years. A month later, Ant Group’s planned $37 billion IPO was cancelled. It was a huge blow to Alibaba’s management and employees because Ant’s IPO was set to be the world’s biggest ever.
Chinese government’s crackdown on Alibaba went beyond the e-commerce and payment business, it also extended to Alibaba’s cloud business, which was once viewed by investors as Alibaba’s next big thing, like Amazon’s
While Munger knew about Chinese’s government’s crackdown on internet companies, he probably was too optimistic on the outcome of the crackdown.
Combining Alibaba’s declining competitive moat, a cultural crisis, a dysfunctional management team, and the government crackdown, we get a powerful “lollapalooza effect” working against Alibaba. I don’t know if Munger realized this powerful lollapalooza effect, but if he did, he probably shouldn’t use leverage to add to Alibaba’s position.
To be fair, Alibaba’s valuation does look cheap. In fact, the most common argument for investing in Alibaba is its low valuation and the massive share buyback program. But the question is, how do you value a declining business? In the past, declining businesses provide a fertile ground for value traps. It’s not that easy to tell at this price, whether Alibaba is a value trap or not.
I have enormous respect for Charlie Munger (Trades, Portfolio). It is both encouraging and saddening to witness his mistake in investing in Alibaba. It is encouraging because it shows that no matter how great you are as a value investor, you still make mistakes. As a young value investor, I can cut myself some slack on my investment mistakes. It is saddening at the same time because I think Munger’s mistake is absolutely avoidable. He relied on his big picture judgment and clearly didn’t do enough research on the business. But at 99 years old, Munger can also cut himself some slack on this mistake. In the end, I want to wish Munger’s Alibaba investment to turn out fine. Time will tell.
There Is Some Good News About Trump’s South Carolina Win
Family Dollar to pay more than $41M fine over rat-infested warehouse
Former MLB Pitcher José DeLeón Dead at 63
Former ‘Two and a Half Men’ Star Angus T. Jones Through the Years
F1 Bahrain Grand Prix 2024: Full race schedule for season opener
The Best Moisturizing Body Washes I’ve Tried for My Super Dry Skin
Get Caught Up in Sydney Sweeney's Euphoric People's Choice Awards 2024
Beyoncé Revealed She’s Dealt With Scalp Psoriasis While Promoting Her New Hair Care Line
People Who Have Had COVID Face a Much Higher Risk of Chronic Fatigue, Study Says
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry Just Fired Back at Critics With 3 Words After Sussex Website Rebrand, Canada Trip
Alabama IVF Patients Are Running Out of Time
Prince William and Kate Middleton Advised to Let World See a ‘Private Moment’ During Recovery to ‘Keep the Rumor Mill From Spinning’
Finally, yes to Sweden in NATO – Asia Times
‘Pokémon Legends: Z-A’ Is Coming in 2025. Will a New Nintendo Switch Join It?
Prince Harry Lost His ‘Safety Blanket of Daddy’s Money’ When He Left the Royal Family
News19 hours ago
In wake of Flaco the owl’s death, New York City lawmaker working on 2 new bills to protect birds
News18 hours ago
Biden Says Israel-Hamas Ceasefire Deal is Just Days Away
Sport20 hours ago
Bills’ Dion Dawkins goes scorched-earth on Jets in interview: ‘I hate them’
News11 hours ago
Three key drivers for the Ukraine war in 2024 – Asia Times
News21 hours ago
Russia’s Online Campaign to Destroy Yulia Navalnaya
Sport6 hours ago
I’m an ex-Prem ace who managed in Sudan & Oman, now my son’s more famous than me
Lifestyle22 hours ago
Score Kelsea Ballerini's Go-To Eyelash Extensions for Just $20
Auto24 hours ago
Subaru, Please Don’t Use Any Of These Names You Just Trademarked