Attorneys have filed dueling motions seeking to claim victory in a federal lawsuit over the Department of Labor’s 2022 environmental, social, and governance rule. Both sides agree on the facts of the case, now it is up to Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk to decide how the law is applied.
ESG is a type of investing where factors beyond strictly financial matters are considered. In concept, ESG is about giving investors the ability to choose how their money is used. Republicans argue it is a way for fund managers to force liberal policies on companies. The lawsuit, brought by 25 Republican led states, revolves around the United States Department of Labor’s passage of a rule allowing ESG factors to be consider in retirement funds.
When Congress passed the Employee Retirement Income Security Act in 1974, they delegated authority to the DOL to regulate standards for pension plans and retirement funds. This process is known as rulemaking, and falls under the Administrative Procedure Act. This delegation of authority and rulemaking process has been the focus of a number of recent opinions by the Supreme Court of the United States.
In 2020, the Trump Administration DOL issued a rule that said investments should be made based on “pecuniary factors” only. The rule was intended to be anti-ESG, however experts felt the rule caused more confusion as the pecuniary factors test was considered vague. In 2022, the Biden Administration DOL issued a new rule saying that investments can consider ESG as a tiebreaker. Only if two funds are projected to produce the same returns, then could the fund manager consider ESG. The new rule allows for the consideration of ESG factors if they are going to make the investment more profitable. How that is factored is yet to be determined. Congress tried to override the new rule, but Biden issued his first veto and reinstated it.
In January, a coalition of Republican states filed litigation in a Texas federal court asserting that the DOL 2022 rulemaking process was improper. Specifically, they stated that the reversal was arbitrary and capricious, language from the APA referring to the need for rulemaking by agencies to be based on facts and with a logical reason.
On May 12, the plaintiffs filed a motion for summary judgement. Unlike a motion to dismiss where the court throws out the litigation, a summary judgment is a final opinion by the judge. A summary judgement is appropriate when the “what happened” part of a case is not disputed. Instead, the argument is over how the law is applied to those facts. The states believe that the facts show the process used by the DOL was in violation of the APA. On June 2, the Department of Justice, which handles all litigation against the Federal Government, responded with their own summary judgement arguing that the DOL process was proper and within their authority granted by Congress.
Notably, the motions were planned in a prior hearing before the judge. The parties agreed that the facts were not in dispute, but the DOL was ordered to turnover their internal rulemaking records. Once the Plaintiffs received the records on May 2, they found nothing in the process that was notably new and quickly filed the motion. This agreement on the facts and process indicates that the judge will choose a side and issue a summary judgement. However, expect the decision to be quickly appealed and work its way to the Supreme Court.
Source: Fox Business
JESSE WATTERS: ‘Gold Bar Bob’ didn’t get this message
Nassau County Exec. Bruce Blakeman urges people to stay in Friday night, but says flooding doesn’t rise to state of emergency
UAE condemns deadly terrorist bombings in Pakistan
D.C. couples rush for marriage licenses as government shutdown looms
Tupac murder suspect arrested and named as Duane Davis – live updates
Some N.H. residents are balking at an ordinance requiring them to cut their lawns
Why Selena Gomez Avoids Her Bedroom During a Bad Mental Health Day
28 Prime Day Kitchen Deals You Can Shop Ahead of Big Deal Days
Dry Brushing Your Skin Has Legit Benefits, According to Experts
Travis Kelce Officially Addresses Taylor Swift Romance Rumors
Jamie Lee Curtis and Lindsay Lohan Had ‘Aggressive Energy’ With Each Other in ‘Freaky Friday’
Dad who won an appeal in college admissions bribery case gets 6 months home confinement for tax offense
Hugh Jackman and Kate Winslet Helped Lure A-List Actors Into a Bad Film They Tried Getting out Of
Risk Management | Definition, Importance, Tools, Best Practices
Watch: Trevor Story snaps the Red Sox’ 23-inning scoreless streak with two-run home run
Tech23 hours ago
H&R Block, Meta, and Google Slapped With RICO Suit, Allegedly Schemed to Scrape Taxpayer Data
News20 hours ago
Netanyahu warns of potential ‘eruption of AI-driven wars’ that could lead to ‘unimaginable’ consequences
News22 hours ago
TSMC to help Europe break its Asia chip dependency
News22 hours ago
Boeing CEO says travel demand recovery is ‘more resilient’ than he imagined
Lifestyle22 hours ago
‘The Golden Bachelor’ Star Gerry Turner Surprises Retirement Home Residents for Premiere Screening (EXCLUSIVE)
Lifestyle20 hours ago
Brittany Snow Is on a ‘Healing Journey’ After Tyler Stanaland Divorce
Sport24 hours ago
Wales captain suffers injury blow and faces fitness race for Euro 2024 qualifier
News21 hours ago
'Felt like a National Geographic scene': Drone video shows jaw-dropping moment shark chases stingrays at Anna Maria Island