Target recently drew the ire of conservatives for LGBTQ+ Pride merchandise. As this action has been speculated to be the result of ESG influence, it is worth looking at Target’s
Environmental, social, and governance, or ESG, is a type of investing where factors beyond strictly financial matters are considered. As ESG investing has increased, publicly traded companies began adding ESG reports to their corporate documents. What companies choose to highlight in these reports vary drastically as no reporting standard currently exists. The Securities and Exchange Commission is currently finalizing reporting standards for the environmental aspect, but social and governance relies on third party organizations.
The social category is the major source of controversy for the right. Diversity, equity, and inclusion, or DEI, programs; policies which target specific industries; and policies tied to political stances are often factors in ESG. Companies may implement programs and internal policies to bolster their ESG Reports. Recently, the focus of controversy has been on outward facing LGBTQ+ polices supporting and promoting the transgender community.
Companies highlight rankings which benefit them, and ignore those which do not. If they are facing pressure from large fund managers to increase a particular score, companies will include goals in their ESG report on how they will improve. This was the case with Anheuser-Busch InBev, the parent company of Budweiser.
Budweiser was the first major company to draw the ire of conservatives by releasing a limited-edition Bud Lite can featuring transgender influencer Dylan Mulvaney. A look at their 2022 ESG Report showed a focus on LGBTQ+ issues and adding influencers to their roster to raise visibility. This leads to a logical conclusion that the Mulvaney decision was, at least in part, influenced by their ESG scores.
Target was next, facing backlash for LGBTQ+ Pride merchandise. A review of Target’s 2022 ESG Report found high scores relating to LGBTQ+ issues and a history of Pride support. Target responded to the controversy by removing some of the clothing and moving the rest to different locations in the store. However, conservative groups are still boycotting the store with many looking to Walmart as an alternative.
This raises the question as to if Walmart’s policies are drastically different from Target’s, or if Walmart has simply avoided the controversy so far. While it is debatable if ESG is driving LGBTQ+ support, the ESG reports do provide valuable information as to the history of the company and how they want to be perceived.
Walmart’s and Target’s 2022 ESG Reports are remarkably similar on LGBTQ+ issues. DiversityInc’s Top Companies for LGBTQ Employees, the standard metric in ESG reports on the internal policies of a company, gave high rankings to both companies. In their 2022 report, Target was ranked #4, while Walmart was ranked #6.
Both companies received a 100% score on the Corporate Equality Index put out by The Human Rights Campaign. CEI is 40% based on outward facing LQBTQ policies, and a company can face an additional 25% penalty for actions which do not support the LGBTQ cause.
A perfect CEI score requires donations to LGBTQ+ causes, refusal to donate to non-religious organizations that discriminate based on LGBTQ+ issues, and support of gender transition. Target’s donations included $2.1 million over 10 years to GLSEN, a nonprofit that focuses on LGBTQ+ inclusivity in schools. Similarly, Walmart donated $500,000 in 2021 to PFLAG, a nonprofit support organization for the LGBTQ+ community.
While the Target controversy originated with their 2023 Pride merchandise, Walmart boasts a similar line on their website. Walmart also highlights LGBTQ+ manufactured products, a shared goal in the ESG reports. Both companies use nearly identical language of encourage the use of diverse suppliers that are at least 51% owned by “woman, minority, veteran, disabled veteran, person with a disability or member of the lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender (LGBT) community.”
The only difference between Target and Walmart on LGBTQ+ issues in their ESG reports is a matter of semantics. Their policies are the same, as are their outward actions to support the LGBTQ+ community. Ultimately, the only reason Target is the focus of conservative pushback while Walmart is avoiding focus may be simply a matter of luck.
Tall ships will return to Boston in 2026
Colorado Mom Suzanne Morphew’s Remains Found 3 Years After She Vanished
American morale remains low on economy, financial future: survey
Taylor Swift, Travis Kelce Crowned "American Royalty" by NFL Analyst
'Stranger Things' Spinoffs We Want to See: Steve, Dustin's Sequel and More
Some N.H. residents are balking at an ordinance requiring them to cut their lawns
How to Stop Protein Farts and Smelly Gas From Ruining Your Workouts
The Biggest Red Flags to Watch Out For at the Dentist
An Arms Workout With Dumbbells to Hit Your Biceps, Triceps and Shoulders
How to Get Better Sleep With Eczema, According to Dermatologists
Tall ships will return to Boston in 2026
Ringo Starr Said He’s Known Best for 2 Things That Have Nothing to Do With Music
Man who was rescued after falling overboard from tanker off Massachusetts has died
The Meta AI Chatbot Is Mark Zuckerberg’s Answer to ChatGPT
‘Survivor 45’ Spoilers: New Twist Might Extend Tribal Council
Tech19 hours ago
NASA’s Perseverance Rover Sets New Speed Records on Mars
News17 hours ago
US sanctions Chinese firms for Russia, Iran drone parts
Lifestyle18 hours ago
Why Julia Fox’s Upcoming Memoir Won't Include Sex With Kanye West
Auto18 hours ago
2023 BMW 530e, 550e PHEV Debut With Up To 489 HP, 62-Mile WLTP Range
Tech18 hours ago
Seattle warehousing startup Flexe lays off 33% of workforce amid freight industry slowdown
Tech19 hours ago
Google quietly corrects previously submitted disclosure for critical webp 0-day
News18 hours ago
Bruins takeaways: Mason Lohrei logs heavy minutes, too many passengers in preseason loss to Sabres
News19 hours ago
Travis Kelce Jersey Sales Soar Following Taylor Swift’s Appearance at Chiefs Game