News
Calls for review of menopause link to poor mental health after woman’s suicide
Published
1 year agoon
By
New Yorker
Sign up for our free Health Check email to receive exclusive analysis on the week in health
Get our free Health Check email
The link between menopause and poor mental health should be reviewed, the health watchdog has said, after an inquiry into a woman’s suicide found staff lack training to spot the risks.
Frances Wellburn, 56, took her own life in 2020 after she was incorrectly assessed as being a “medium risk” of suicide by Tees, Esk and Wear NHS Trust (TEWV).
A national study by the Health and Safety Investigation Branch (HSIB), prompted by her death, warned that this was a national problem, with funding and capacity problems driving staff to use ineffective “checklist” tools when assessing suicidal patients.
The HSIB also found staff were not trained to spot mental health risks associated with menopause, and menopause is not routinely considered a contributing factor among women with low mood who need help.
It said that women are often prescribed antidepressants when hormone replacement therapy (HRT) would be more appropriate.
Are you affected by this story? Email [email protected]
In Ms Wellburn’s case, HSIB found TEWV staff had failed to take into account that she was going through menopause when they assessed her as being at medium risk of self-harm. This went against national guidance, which states scales should not be used to predict future suicide or self-harm.
The trust has previously been criticised in independent inquiries for systemic failings which led to the deaths of three young women in inpatient units.
The report warned that NHS hospitals are not adequately managing suicidal patients, with many assessed as “low” or “moderate” risk going on to take their own lives.
The watchdog said hospitals commonly used such “checklists” to assess patients’ suicide risk, with clinicians warning that categorising patients as low risk was often used as a justification not to provide care. NHS England told HSIB it had since written to all hospitals reminding them not to use this scale.
The report also raised concerns that patients were being wrongly refused early intervention psychosis care based on their age – despite guidance in 2016 ruling this should not be a factor.
According to an internal serious incident report by TEWV in 2020, trust staff held a “false view that due to Frances’ age (>35) and diagnosis of ‘depression with psychotic features’ that she would not be considered for assessment by the EIP service”.
Early intervention in psychosis services are community-based services aimed at people who are experiencing psychosis for the first time. These services were initially aimed at people aged 14 to 35 however the guidance changed in 2016 to remove the age limit. According to HSIB’s report, staff claimed she was not referred to EIP services because they thought community services would be more appropriate.
The HSIB investigation found some trusts are still prioritising young patients for early intervention in psychosis services due to problems related to funding, capacity, and “misconceptions” over whether an older person can be experiencing a first episode of psychosis later in life.
According to the latest NHS data, just 44 per cent of EIP services in England are meeting the highest level of National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guidance, against a target of at least 70 per cent.
Experts quoted in the report said it would be beneficial to have women-specific healthcare services and mental health treatments designed to account for age and sex.
In a statement reacting to the report, MsWellburns’ sister said: “In the last 10 months of my sister’s life she was thrown into unknown territory as she experienced a first episode of psychosis. She became convinced that people close to her were trying to harm her and she lost all trust in everything that had previously given her life meaning. This frightening world became her reality, and she lost the ability to see what was happening to her as an illness she could recover from.”
“Our family have shared information about my sister’s experience in the hope that others like her can be better supported to stay safe and recover.”
An NHS England spokesperson: “There is clear evidence that risk assessment tools are not an effective basis on which to predict future suicidal behaviour or incidents of self-harm and should not be used to decide who should be offered treatment.
“We are asking all services to review the use of risk assessment tools and scales and to develop more personalised approaches to safety planning, with tailored assessment and management of an individual’s needs, risks and contexts.”
The CQC said it welcomed HSIB’s recommendations on improving its inspections of community mental health care.
A spokesperson for TEWV: “We fully support the findings and recommendations in the HSIB report into care delivery within community mental health teams. We will keep working closely with our partners in the wider health and social care system to make sure improvements are made.”
Source: Independent
Prince Louis Is All Grown Up in Royally Sweet 6th Birthday Portrait
Run to Walmart Now To Snag This $7 2-Piece Crop Top Set
Ex-NFL star Shawne Merriman wishes young QBs got more time to develop | Fox News Video
Ayrton Senna’s ‘most famous’ car pops up on Auto Trader for £500k
Mandarin Oriental Hyde Park, London launches brand new culinary adventure ‘LUCHO’
How to Follow the WNBA Draft If You’re Newly Obsessed With Women’s Basketball
How to Clear a Stuffy Nose Fast—And Get Back to Breathing Normally
This Easy Addition to Your Egg Muffins Will Double Your Protein at Breakfast
Learning to Swim as an Adult Feels Like Coming Home
17 Comforting Recipes to Bring to a Friend Who Is Grieving
Elehear’s Alpha Pro OTC Hearing Aids Have Great Battery Life
Iran’s North Koreanization gambit – Asia Times
A National Security Insider Does the Math on the Dangers of AI
King Charles’s ‘Cruel Rejection’ Left Prince Harry ‘Furious and in Tears’ About Frogmore Cottage — Author
Yuan internationalization drive hits a local speed bump – Asia Times
Trending
-
Wellness21 hours ago
This Is What a 52-Year-Old Face Without Filters or Makeup Looks Like
-
Travel22 hours ago
Marriott International Celebrates Milestone on Journey Towards Net-Zero
-
News23 hours ago
We Tested the BYD Seal—the Car That Explains Why Tesla Just Cut Its Prices
-
Tech24 hours ago
Meet QDEL, the backlight-less display tech that could replace OLED in premium TVs
-
Auto20 hours ago
The Mercedes AMG GT Hybrid Has 9 Miles Of Electric Range On Purpose
-
Travel21 hours ago
Medical Translation: Facilitating Global Healthcare Through Language
-
Travel24 hours ago
Interview – Mark De Cocinis, CEO of Boutique Group
-
Sport20 hours ago
Dolphins’ Tua Tagovailoa credits younger brother for being ‘support system,’ offers him NFL Draft advice