Had Deng Xiaoping not sought and received advice from Japan and Singapore in his creation of “socialism with Japanese and Singaporean characteristics,” China’s economic miracle would have been less miraculous. China’s current economic woes stem largely from Xi Jinping’s abandonment of this paradigm.
When Mao Zedong died in 1976, China was the second poorest among 140 countries. Deng Xiaoping proclaimed a remedy of “reform and opening up” to foreign countries, drawing from previous Asian success stories. During an October 1978 trip to Japan, Deng met with business leaders, toured a Nissan auto plant and saw China’s future.
“We are a backward country and we need to learn from Japan,” he told a press conference in Tokyo. His first official foreign economic advisor was Saburo Okita, one of the legendary architects of Japan’s economic miracle. Over the years, 22,000 advisors from Singapore came to China.
Instead of Mao’s command economy dominated by state-owned enterprises (SOEs), the government adopted a Japan-style industrial policy. Deng combined various governmental measures to direct resources to modern industry, leveraging the efficiency of private firms.
To avoid the pitfalls associated with economies favoring a single “national champion” across assorted industries, it becomes imperative for private companies to engage in healthy competition. By 2018, SOEs dwindled to 12% of urban employment and exports and one-third of business investment.
SOEs never could have created the economic miracle. Nearly half of SOEs regularly run losses, causing the economy to shrink every time they make a product. Even profitable SOEs create less growth than private companies for every yuan invested.
In a reversal of that record, Xi is resurrecting SOE dominance. In 2012, before Xi ascended, only 32% of bank loans went to SOEs. By 2016, SOEs received 83%, but these loans took a while to translate into a stronger presence in investment and employment.
This policy reversal stemmed from the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) worries that private companies could become a separate locus of power. In addition, Xi has compelled many private companies to accept interference from CCP branches in their management decisions, resulting in declining efficiency, as measured by return-on-assets.
Equally indispensable to growth are the foreign companies that transfer technology and drive exports. As in Japan, exports facilitated industrialization because, when Deng began, China’s people were still too poor to buy modern factory goods and could not yet produce goods that were competitive in the global market.
Singapore proposed to Beijing its own strategic solution — bringing foreign companies to China to make and export products. By 2000, according to the International Monetary Fund, foreign multinationals produced half of China’s exports, especially high-tech items.
Foreign companies exported 100% of computer products, compared to 40% of clothing. This process transferred knowledge to all new private companies that supplied 80% of the content of these exports and even to unrelated firms.
While Xi does not want to isolate China, he believes China would be more secure if it were less dependent on foreign technology and firms. He asserts that China no longer needs foreign technology as much as before.
Xi is miscalculating. In 2015, he launched a “Made in China 2025” program aimed at becoming self-sufficient and achieving global supremacy in several pivotal technologies and products. The program has fallen short.
For example, China’s tax breaks for companies issuing lots of patents caused them to shift from high-quality patents to lower-quality ones. That has actually reduced innovation, according to a study by Chinese academics.
While China has made tremendous strides in some technologies and created some world-class companies like Huawei, driving away foreign firms hurts innovation and growth.
Before Xi’s rise, foreign firms suffered procurement discrimination and intellectual property theft, but the situation has escalated in both frequency and severity. It now includes arrests of foreign personnel on dubious charges of espionage, along with demands that foreign firms involve CCP branches in business decisions.
As sales in China decrease, companies are less willing to tolerate such impositions. Foreign direct investment into China from all countries plunged by 8% in the first eight months of 2023.
The clampdown on private and foreign companies couldn’t come at a worse time. With the labor force shrinking and private investment decelerating, China cannot grow well unless it increases growth in total factor productivity (TFP) – more output from those labor and capital inputs.
During 1980–2010, TFP accounted for about 40% of the growth in GDP per worker. Under Xi, the TFP growth rate has plunged by two-thirds, which is one of the biggest drivers for China’s per capita GDP growth halving from 9% in the decade before Xi ascended to a forecasted 4% or less in the coming five years.
Rather than correct this productivity drop, Beijing tried to boost growth by building a surplus of “apartments for no one,” financed by excessive debt. This has resulted in financial turmoil and demonstrations from buyers still waiting for their homes.
Xi is either deceiving himself about the causes of China’s economic headwinds or demonstrating his willingness to sacrifice economic growth to pursue political goals at home and abroad. The effect of weaker growth on political stability is yet to be determined.
Richard Katz is Senior Fellow at the Carnegie Council for Ethics in International Affairs.
This article was originally published by East Asia Forum and is republished under a Creative Commons license.
Source: Asia Times
Florida woman allegedly poisons boyfriend’s tea with bleach tablet: report
Connecticut family meets living donor who saved 4-year-old son’s life
Takeaways from the Michigan primary
Judge slaps down rogue Michigan Republican chairwoman who refused to leave post
Tyreek Hill broke Pasco County woman's leg during football lesson at his Florida home, lawsuit says
The Best Moisturizing Body Washes I’ve Tried for My Super Dry Skin
Beyoncé Revealed She’s Dealt With Scalp Psoriasis While Promoting Her New Hair Care Line
People Who Have Had COVID Face a Much Higher Risk of Chronic Fatigue, Study Says
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry Just Fired Back at Critics With 3 Words After Sussex Website Rebrand, Canada Trip
17 Women Share the Reasons They Stopped Wearing Makeup
‘Little People, Big World’: Caryn Chandler Lists Oregon Home for $540,000 After Moving to Roloff Farms
Margot Robbie Was Worried About Being Typecast After ‘Wolf of Wall Street’
Charles Barkley Addresses His Relationship With Madonna and Reveals if They Really Did Date at One Point
A Major ‘Stardew Valley’ Update Is Coming in March
Paul McCartney Wrote 1 Beatles Song After a ‘Mystical Religious Experience’
News21 hours ago
Three key drivers for the Ukraine war in 2024 – Asia Times
Sport15 hours ago
I’m an ex-Prem ace who managed in Sudan & Oman, now my son’s more famous than me
Tech11 hours ago
Updates From The Mandalorian & Grogu, and More
Lifestyle21 hours ago
Gerard Butler’s ‘Has Fallen’ Film Franchise Gets an Event TV Series Makeover in Studiocanal’s ‘Paris Has Fallen’
News11 hours ago
Lawsuit alleges New York doctor died of allergic reaction after eating at Disney World restaurant
Tech23 hours ago
Google Will Relaunch Gemini in a ‘Few Weeks,’ After Its Racial Controversy
News15 hours ago
Camilla takes the reigns as head of the Royal family: Confident-looking Queen steps up to represent the British monarchy at memorial service attended by whole host of European royals in Charles’ absence
Tech24 hours ago
What Is ANC and Why Do I Need It in My Headphones?