Finance
SVB’s Collapse Is A Lesson In Personal And Corporate Greed
Published
1 year agoon
By
James White
In the wake of the spectacular collapse of Silicon Valley Bank, regulators, investors, and depositors are all seeking answers. How could an institution that had so recently been lauded fail so suddenly? While at SVB there were clearly problems with risk management (the standard practice of calculating and hedging risks at banks and financial institutions) — it even operated for months last year without a chief risk officer — it’s really a symptom of a more serious, underlying issue: The banking system hasn’t learned the hard lessons from the 2008 financial crisis.
In 2008, one of the greatest companies in the world, Merrill Lynch (the institution where I got my start in business and worked from 1984 to 2001), blew up because of greed and a lack of accountability. Not one executive had to give back a dime! It shouldn’t have happened then, and it shouldn’t have happened again, but it just did with SVB. We are fortunate that SVB’s collapse doesn’t seem like it’s going to endanger the global financial system, however, the executives who made money even as risk management broke down should still face serious consequences, including clawing back bonuses.
Why Did SVB Collapse?
Executives on Wall Street, and at banks generally, get bonuses. Most people on Wall Street and in the financial industry are not driven by greed, but those who are tend to make decisions that are in their own best interest, not necessarily in the long-term best interest of their employees, clients, and shareholders. They want to earn more money. On top of that, it’s also a competitive industry where people, executives, and institutions are always looking at the other guy. There’s pressure from shareholders — and from people seeking bonuses — to double-down on strategies that make money and seem “safe.” Growing greed leads people to take on increased risk.
Of course, risk is a necessary part of investing. Without risk, there’s no return. The problem is when people allow their greed to interfere with their risk tolerance.
Good Risk Vs. Bad Risk
You never want to take on existential risk. Investors and bank executives must always examine their investments, how they could turn against them, and how much damage would be done if those investments went the wrong way. Unfortunately, when people think something is safe — and they’re making a ton of money from it — greed starts to undermine their ability to think clearly. When investors get greedy, something that may have been only moderately risky at a low level of investment — meaning that you would take a hit if it collapsed but would still be able to fight another day — can easily grow to a level where it could undermine the whole institution if something goes wrong.
This is what happened during the 2008 financial crisis. Investors were earning huge amounts of money on mortgage backed securities. Since they were considered safe, they kept piling in without thinking about what fissures in the housing market would mean for their institutions.
A similar dynamic seems to have played out at SVB. The institution grew its deposits dramatically as the tech industry boomed in recent years, from $102 billion at the end of 2020 to $189 billion by the end of 2021. Those deposits were piled into Treasury and mortgage bonds, seemingly without questioning how much risk they faced if interest rates began to rise or how they would respond to a bank run. (This is risk management 101 for banks! Perhaps they would have known this, except that from October 2022 until January 2023, there was no chief risk officer at SVB. At a minimum, that’s a failure of good succession planning.)
Yet, since deposits continued to surge — and interest rates had been at historic lows for years — they didn’t consider the existential risk they might be taking on until it was too late. They let greed get the better of them and crowd out sober analysis of risk. On top of the $9.9 million in total compensation former SVB CEO Greg Becker earned last year, he sold $3.6 million of stock just days before the bank collapsed. Executives like him were making huge amounts of money, but they were doing it without sound risk management practices.
The implosion of SVB is a big problem, and it speaks to serious issues within the financial world. Unfortunately, you don’t just get a problem solved overnight. First you must understand what exactly the problem is and then define a specific regulatory fix for it. If a bank is having difficulty, there should be a forensic investigation of how much money they made from those practices during the previous few years. Executive bonuses from that period should be on the chopping block.
Risk-taking is a good thing when it is calculated, and the best investors understand how much risk is appropriate for themselves and their institutions. But when greed gets in the way, problems inevitably arise, and risk becomes an existential matter. It’s time for the financial industry — and regulators — to take this seriously.
Source: Fox Business
Tech Moves: Seattle tech vet Dave Parker named CEO of Entrepreneurs’ Organization
White branded a ‘menace’ as fans spot what he did to Vicario before Arsenal goal
World of Hyatt Elevates Luxury Portfolio
Texas pregnancy center provides faith-centered ‘holistic care’ for women in crisis
Thunderstorms possible around NYC as region sees major warmup
This Easy Addition to Your Egg Muffins Will Double Your Protein at Breakfast
17 Comforting Recipes to Bring to a Friend Who Is Grieving
Olivia Munn’s Cancer Treatment Led to ‘Medically Induced Menopause’—Here’s What That Means
The Truth About Popular Sleep Supplements, From Magnesium to Melatonin
What My First Time Having Sex After Giving Birth Felt Like
Ceretone’s Core One Over-the-Counter Hearing Aids Are Near Invisible, and Barely Helpful
Jerry Seinfeld Once Scrapped a Reunion ‘Seinfeld’ Episode Because It Was Too Late
The smart money has AI in its portfolio – Asia Times
Bruins forward James van Riemsdyk is skating confidently against his former team
How to Get Free Kindle Books With Your Library Card
Trending
-
Lifestyle2 hours ago
Colin Jost Wins Over Tough White House Correspondents Dinner Crowd With Praise for ‘Decent’ Biden
-
News2 hours ago
Chinese EV makers zooming by pioneer Tesla – Asia Times
-
News3 hours ago
Biden places politics over strategy in US Steel sale – Asia Times
-
Tech2 hours ago
There’s never been a better time to get into Fallout 76
-
Sport3 hours ago
Colts owner Jim Irsay denies he overdosed when police found him unresponsive in December
-
Wellness3 hours ago
I Was Told I Had an STI. It Was Actually Cervical Cancer
-
News2 hours ago
Hong Kong exports rebound despite Sino-US trade war – Asia Times
-
Tech2 hours ago
Seattle mayor joins tech leaders on Homeland Security’s new AI safety and security board